Bianca Ryan VS Charice Pempengco
Posted on 24. Jun, 2007 by Alicia in General
The hottest topic in youtube, two young lady, 11 year old Bianca and 12 year old Charice were being compared by everyone. Who sings better and who is not? You decide.
Someone being nice to compile the videos into one and got it uploaded to youtube. You should not miss it.
both are very good…. i can’t decide… grRr
hmmm…this is a tough one but charise seems to have the edge, both have a great voice but charise have the edge, she can capture an audience with her charm and better stage presentation for now..ask me the same question 10 yrs from now
charice is the most talented singer i have heard in my whole life! her talent is out of this world! mamamia! i love her forever! cha, i will always love u! for bianca, better luck next tym gurl! need pracrice!
who’s better? comparatively, the girl who has the range and quality of voice which means charice. bianca’s voice just couldn’t catch my attention. no feelings, very monotonous, no versatility in her style and struggles to reach her high notes. just being honest. i sing too so i know that charice hits all her notes with quality. it doesn’t matter who she copies cuz she gives justice to the song and the artist. truth is, you can never tell whether she’s singling live or recording cuz she’s got the voice to listen to.
both girls should perform in a face off concert and let people choose who’s better or whose hot and not, aye. anyone agree with my idea?
im not being bias by choosing charise as my favorite (im filipino too), but anyone who’s a music fan can tell the difference, she’s just a great talent, she has the passion and the range to hit all the right notes
i love them both.but i really have goosebumps when charice pempengco sang “listen “by beyonce “and im telling you” in korea “if i were you” by tamia, i really was amazed too when i first hear bianca’s rendtion of “and im telling you”
bianca is the girl charice is measured against? nah, just listen to bianca scream for milk, one tone, ha ha ha. if you think bianca is a better singer than charice, you’re all deaf, bianca ryan is a second rated trying hard singer.
you heard both girls sing live in their videos, the video speaks for itself, now you judge. the credit goes to charice, period.
charice is one great talent .i mean man!she’s the best!i’m speechless…….
she is the best among young female singers. but i like sarah geronimo than her
charice really hit it big. she has a better voice than bianca
Charice Pempengco is the best, both voice quality and stage presence.
no doubt! charice is the best!
of course no doubt charise being a filipino is truly a world class performer…she is the best!
WOW!!!! I CAN’T BELIEVE THIS…. CHARICE’ PERFORMACE WAS AMAZING. HER STAGE PRESENCE WAS REALLY CAPTIVATING. SHE HAS A DIVALICIOUS SINGING VOICE…. THERE’S NO DOUBT, CHARICE GOT IT!!!
NO DOUBT! CHARICE IS A LOT BETTER!
LET”S HAVE A FACE OFF !
Oh! My goodness that girl name CHARICE, got amazing voice and very incredible. I saw her performance on Ellen. I kicked my ass after i watch it. WOWOWOWOW
CharisE is SOOOOOOOOO great!!! I LOVE Bianca Ryan ^__^ They are both good don’t ‘ya think??
Bianca is better……………. urrr… uhhh… can’t take lying…. CHARICE IS BETTER even compare her to beyonce most likely you’d choose Charice… first of all….. if you count the age….. it’s like 10 age difference…. Honestly…. Bianca’s voice hurts my ears…. I can’t take it… I don’t want to listen to voices like that…. and yeah… her mic hold (most of the time) is not even in front of her mouth… it’s on the side of the mouth….. truly…. some filipino singers (including me) were taught to make the stage small with their performance (if the song is lively)… tell me… doesn’t that impact you more???
well… honestly It’s my first time having an idol and it’s charice…. well good luck to her
they’re both great. i like bianca better. she got here first.
OMG…i can’t decide, Charice’s was powerful and phenomenal, and Bianca cherises and pleasures every person on her great singing!!!
it would be unfair for Bianca to be compared to Charice; as it would be absurd to compare an amateur to a professional singer.
with that said, charice is on a league comparable only to professional adult singers, while bianca, sadly, isn’t on a level as close to charice’s.
if one would just listen you can hear basically that there’s no way bianca can even get close to the variety of octaves and melodies that charice can belt out.
one tip for someone to really compare is to just close your eyes and listen to the way they sing.
it would be quite obvious even at the start… that bianca is a basically an 11-year old kid with high-tone sometimes squeky-voice – good enough for an 11-year olds – but that’s it, nothing fancy,nothing great.
while charice is on the other hand, a 15-yr-old girl with an outstanding full range of voice comparable only to adult professional singers of our generation.
We haven’t seen a talent like this for a long time. The way she sings and hit those high notes sends shivers all over!!!! GOSH!!! and she is only 15 years old?!!! MY GOD!!!!
SHE’S JUST PHENOMENAL!!!!!
they are both great singers for there age. good luck to them both.
Bianca sang only one good part of the song And I am telling you I’m not going with gusto. While Charice belted the song with gusto from start to finish. That is only my observation. I maybe wrong and biased.
We’re always surprise with the singer that not black men cause we know black men has body structure that benefit to be a singer first,there lung muscle. Second face structure look like speaker and last glottal(in this case not only black men).But when we found other people that can sing like(or better) black men we ‘re surprise That is a Gifted, God bless!!!!!
In my onpinion Cherice better than Bianca Cause
1. Charice sound deep like the Ocean but Bianca shallow like swamp
2. Charice range like syberian railway but Bianca like Thai railway
3. Charice voice massure like jupiter but Bianca like mar
4. Charice voice sweet like morning sunlight but Bianca like noon sunlike that burnt me!!!!!
5. I alway love Charice than Biaca haha
Sorry With my oppinion but This for funny don’t be serious
Charice has one great disadvantage. Her lack of immersion in the music (Jennifer Holliday) shows. While Charice may or may not have more range than Bianca, she can’t carry the song. In the words of James Brown, “She ain’t got no Soul”
Watch the original by Jennifer Holliday and you’ll see for yourself. The song these two girls, and thousands of others, riff off of starts half way through. Bianca and Charice may have talent, but for THIS song, Jennifer Holliday has absolutely no true competition.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kC_u_q-iND0
One more. The following link is a duet of this song between the original, Jennifer Holliday and Bianca Ryan.
That’s soul.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9DU1aN0lv8Q&feature=related
GO Charice!!! Well Charice is better than Bianca..She’s amazing and fantastic..
To Honest. First off, we are comparing CHARICE and Bianca.
NOT Jennifer Holliday.
And are you BLIND!
Just watch Charice onstage and you can see she has more soul than most singers, especially Bianca. She has so much soul into her singing it’s amazing it can fit in her small form.
To me Charice is WAY better. She’s PROFESSIONAL.
Bianca has a nice voice but she can’t TOUCH Charice in singing.
Bianca’s voice is too screechy and squeaky. Not that good of tone.
Charice is better than Bianca –
Bianca has no feelings or emotions – no Power!
But Charice – she nAiled it.
Charice is a star now!
Hands down, Charice is in her own plane….. above thr rest!
BOTH ARE REALLY GOOD BUT I THINK OFCOURSE CHARICE IS THE ONE WHO REALLY DESERVES THE WORLD SHE GOT ME STRAIGHT IN THE EARS FIRST TIME I HEARD HER SANG SHE IS AN AMAZING YOUNG TALENTED GIRL AS BIANCA BUT NO BETTER THAN BIANCA OFCOURSE 10 FOR BIANCA 10000 FOR CHARICE
Whoa!!!??
Such a close one!!
Charice is so Fantastic!
beCauSe………
BiancA has no emotions afterall!… ~_o
There is no comparison. Charice is much much much better than Bianca. Charice has that ‘one in a million’ type voice and she sings every song with appropriate passion and power. Just observe Ellen’s reaction when both performanced at Ellen’s show and you can tell who’d she would pick (if asked).
I really don’t want to see them both sing against each other, these are still kids and who have talents on their own way. I think it will be nice to see them sing together in a way that they don’t compete each other. We have enough rivalry going on in this world. I congratulate this 2 kids with their gift of talents. more success.
Eh.. you don’t need to compare them both because they are both great singers… but i would really choose Charice because of her voice quality ..bianca has a good voice too but it’s not that much compared to charice.. like them both..
but i still vote for charice =]
There’s no need to compare..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=douoYf6JsjE
just watch it and see !
BIANCA RYAN IS A GOOD SINGER BUT MOST OF THE TIME SHE SOUNDS SQUEAKY ESPCIALLY WHEN HITTING HIGH NOTES. SHE CAN BE VERY GOOD IN SINGING KIDDY SONGS OR CHRISTMAS ONES! COMPARE TO CHARICE SHE’S WAY TOO FAR DEAR! JUST LISTEN TO BIANCA WHEN SHE SINGS LOTS OF ERRORS!
CHARICE IS REALLY GOOD! NO DOUBT!
ONE MORE THING BIANCA EATS HER WORDS WHEN SHE’S SINGING AND ALMOST WANT TO CRY CAUSE SHE CANT HIT THE NOTES/ TRY ONE TIME TO LISTEN OF HER RENDITION OF “LISTEN”. GOD NOTHING TO WHAT CHARICE HAVE DONE WITH THE SONG. BIANCA RUINED THE SONG. SHE SHOULDNT EVEN HAVE TRIED. I FEEL SORRY FOR HER. THATS WHY DAVID FOSTER MAY HAVE CHOSEN CHARICE OVER BIANCA. I DONT EVEN THINK HE HAVE EVER THOUGHT OF BIANCA! SORRY…
GO CHARICE
They are both gud singersssss
charice is the best
i don’t like bianca’s voice
i loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee charice bianca is i dont know i dont like the voice of bianca
go go go go go charice {i am a filipina too} oh i’m sorry bianca but what i love most is charice pempengco she is so so so so so so so so so so so so very good
i hope i will see charice pempengco {im a filipina too} im here in canada
charice is short for her age, filipinos have alot of talented singers, sarah geronimo if she would of switched paths with charice, sarah wouldve of been a bigger international star, charice looks like a troll now, cute before troll now